Voigtlander Camera Lenses: A Comparative Analysis
Choosing the right lens can significantly impact the quality of your photography. In this article, we explore the performance of Voigtlander camera lenses and compare them with those from well-known brands like Canon and Nikon. We also discuss the practical aspects of using Voigtlander lenses and their production background.
Introduction to Voigtlander Lenses
Voigtlander has a rich history in the lens manufacturing industry. Traditionally, Voigtlander lenses were prized for their exceptional quality and fine craftsmanship. However, the brand ceased to exist in 2014, and modern Voigtlander lenses are now produced by Cosina. Cosina, having been in the lens-making business since the 1960s, is known for its technological expertise and high-quality production methods. This, in turn, makes modern Voigtlander lenses a compelling choice for many photographers.
Quality and Performance
One of the primary factors considered when choosing a lens is the quality/price ratio. Voigtlander lenses, especially when compared to their proprietary Leica counterparts, offer a remarkable balance. The quality of Voigtlander lenses is often highlighted in various YouTube reviews and comparisons. However, it is important to note that lab conditions often do not reflect real-world photography. The skill of the photographer plays a crucial role in determining the quality of the final image.
Despite being produced by Cosina, Voigtlander lenses are still valued for their unique qualities. For instance, the Noktons series, including the 21mm, 40mm, and 75mm, are well-regarded for their exceptional performance on the M10-R. Similarly, the 35mm ASPH F/1.4 Summilux lens on the M9-P is highly praised. These lenses, while not as powerful as some of the high-end Canon or Nikon lenses, offer a range of superb qualities that are often more affordable and easier to handle.
Practical Considerations
The ease of manual focusing with Voigtlander lenses on modern autofocus bodies is debatable. While many modern lenses are designed with autofocus in mind, Voigtlander lenses work exceptionally well with rangefinder cameras like the Leica M series. The build quality of Voigtlander lenses is another aspect that deserves attention. The Noktons, for example, fit comfortably in the palm of your hand, despite their weight and robust construction.
A notable feature of Voigtlander lenses is the lens hood, which can be useful when using polarizing filters. Unlike some other lenses, the Voigtlander hood is not reversible for storage, so photographers must consider this when deciding which lens to use.
Comparing Voigtlander with Canon and Nikon
When comparing Voigtlander lenses with those from Canon and Nikon, it is essential to define what "better" means. While modern Canon and Nikon lenses often dominate in terms of megapixels and advanced features, Voigtlander lenses excel in specific areas like optical quality and build. For instance, while a 400mm f/3.5 Nikkor may excel in certain applications, it is not available for Voigtlander users. Instead, alternative lenses from manufacturers like TTArtisan and Light Lens Lab offer outstanding performance at a lower cost.
Ultimately, the choice between Voigtlander and Canon/Nikon lenses depends on the photographer's specific needs and preferences. Voigtlander lenses offer a balance of quality and affordability, making them a great option for photographers seeking an excellent value proposition.