Pencil Drawings vs Digital Art: Which Is Harder?

The difficulty between pencil drawings and digital art varies from artist to artist. Pencil drawings demand mastering techniques such as shading and blending by hand, while digital art requires proficiency in software and digital tools. This article explores both mediums to help artists find the one that suits their style and preferences.

Challenges in Transitioning from Traditional to Digital Art

Here are two common challenges faced by artists when transitioning from traditional to digital art, along with practical solutions to overcome them.

Challenge 1: Texture of the Tablet

When drawing traditionally, you “feel” the friction of the pencil and the paint layer on the canvas. However, drawing on a digital tablet is different. Traditional art offers a tactile experience, which can feel smoother and more natural. When starting with a digital tablet, the feeling of smooth plastic on smooth plastic can be strange and even frustrating. Here are some solutions to make the transition smoother:

Use real paper: Tape real paper onto your Intuos tablet to create some friction. This is effective for tablets that are not the screen itself. Develop dexterity: Improve your dexterity by spending more time drawing on the tablet. Regular practice will eventually help you adapt to the new medium.

Every artist must find their own way to adapt, and patience is key.

Challenge 2: Learning Software

Using digital software can be daunting, especially for artists who are accustomed to traditional tools. However, learning a new program to paint is completely manageable with the right approach:

Tutorial learning: Get a tutorial and learn how to use a program like Photoshop. Start with hotkeys and common tasks to get familiar with the software. Mileage is key: Practice regularly to master the software. Once you learn the program, it will serve you well, and you won't have to relearn it for each project.

Remember, learning the software is a one-time effort, and there are not many critical things you need to know to paint effectively.

Art and the Senses: Drawing vs Digital Art

Art is not just about the final product; it's about the experience. Traditional art engages multiple senses, making it a more immersive process. Here are a few points to consider:

Hand and Eye Coordination: Drawing requires your hand and eye to work together in a way that integrates touch, vision, and motor skills. This synergy is hard to replicate with just a computer screen. No Distractions: When you are drawing, your attention is solely on the task at hand, and distractions such as thoughts or peripheral vision do not interfere. On the other hand, digital art involves constant interaction with the software, which can be a source of distraction.

For a truly authentic art experience, try a method where you draw a point on a large piece of paper. Look only at the point and draw the wildest line with loops and zigzags that moves towards it but never looks at your hand or the line. If you have the peripheral vision flying saucer, you might even be able to keep your peripheral vision focused on the point. You will find this exact point every time, even if you are thinking that it is impossible. Repeat the same exercise with your other hand while watching the point. This exercise will show you the true essence of drawing.

Now try the same exercise on a computer. You will notice that it is significantly more challenging because the computer and software get in the way. The computer might feel necessary, but it does introduce an element of detachment.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both traditional pencil drawings and digital art have their unique challenges and rewards. Whether you choose one over the other depends on your personal style and preferences. Both methods require a lot of practice, but they offer different kinds of learning experiences. Whether you prefer the tactile experience of traditional art or the precision of digital tools, the key is to find the method that resonates with you the most.