Is a Shure SM57 Suitable for Vocals?
The Shure SM57 is a versatile microphone that has found its way into many different applications, from live performances to studio recordings. Despite its broad utility, its suitability for voicings has been a topic of discussion among audio professionals and enthusiasts. In this article, we will explore the capabilities of the SM57 for vocals and compare it with alternatives like the SM58.
Multi-Task Capabilities of the Shure SM57
The SM57 is known for its versatility, being able to handle a wide range of applications, including vocals. It has been used for presidential addresses, various types of recording, and live performances. However, when it comes to the dedicated task of voicings, opinions vary.
Preference for the SM58
Many audio professionals prefer the Shure SM58 over the SM57 for vocals. The SM58 includes a blast/pop filter, which is essential for capturing clear and articulate close-up vocals. Despite both microphones being in the same price range, the additional features of the SM58 often outweigh its cost.
Detailed Comparison and Personal Experiences
Several tests have been conducted to compare the performance of the SM57 against other microphones ranging from a few dollars to thousands of dollars. No participant in any of these tests could identify differences between the microphones, including the Shure U87A, known for its studio quality.
Live Performance vs. Studio Use
The SM57 is particularly well-suited for live performances where it can deliver rich and warm vocals. Some professionals still use it for recording guitar amplifiers and drums, highlighting its versatility. While it can perform adequately for vocals, it may not offer the same level of clarity and articulation as the SM58, which has been a industry standard for years.
Conclusion and Recommendations
The Shure SM57 is a reliable microphone with a wide range of applications. While it can be used for vocals, its performance may not be as optimal as the SM58, especially for close-up recording where clarity and articulation are crucial. For those seeking a microphone that excels in vocals, the SM58 remains a popular choice. However, for live performances where warmth and versatility over personality are more important, the SM57 still stands as a worthy option.
Key Takeaways
The Shure SM57 is a versatile microphone suitable for a wide range of applications, including vocals. The SM58 is generally preferred for vocals due to its inclusion of a pop filter and superior clarity for close-up recording. No significant differences were found in blind tests involving high-end microphones. The SM57 is well-suited for live performances and guitar/drums, but not as ideal for studio vocal recordings.For those interested in audio equipment, exploring the differences and choosing the right microphone for your specific needs is crucial. Whether you are recording a spoken word performance or creating a professional studio album, understanding the nuances of each microphone can significantly enhance your audio output.