Choosing the Right Laptop for University Work: MacBook Air 2017 vs. Lenovo ThinkPad A285
When preparing for university, selecting the right laptop is a crucial decision. In this article, we will compare two notable options: the MacBook Air 2017 and the Lenovo ThinkPad A285 2018. Both laptops fit within a typical budget for a student, but which one is the better fit for your university needs?
Operating System Considerations
A key factor in choosing between these laptops is the operating system (OS) they support. The latest OS that the MacBook Air 2017 can run is macOS Monterey, which was released in 2021. Apple is known for its long support cycles, but the last update is expected later in 2024. After that, security fixes may cease, posing a potential security risk.
In contrast, the Lenovo ThinkPad A285 AFAIK is not on the Windows 11 upgrade list. Windows 10, currently installed on the ThinkPad, will stop receiving security updates in 2025. Although it is possible to install Windows 11 on the Lenovo, there have been reports of issues and potential future incompatibilities.
Alternative Operating Systems
For both laptops, you could opt for alternative operating systems such as Linux distributions like Ubuntu, Zorin, and Mint Cinnamon. These systems offer a robust and reliable environment that can run smoothly on these older hardware configurations.
Energy and Performance Considerations
Another important factor to consider is the battery performance. A laptop that is over 4 years old, like the MacBook Air 2017 and the Lenovo ThinkPad A285, may not sustain a full charge for more than an hour. This can be a significant inconvenience, especially if you need to use the laptop away from a power source.
Performance is another key consideration. The older hardware may struggle to keep up with current software, especially if you plan to run resource-intensive applications. Both the MacBook Air 2017 and the Lenovo ThinkPad A285 have chips that may need to be updated, though they should still provide decent performance for most university workloads.
Attaching Devices and Future Proofing
Deciding between these two laptops also depends on your needs for attaching external devices. The MacBook Air 2017 has a limited number of ports, which may be a disadvantage if you need to connect multiple devices. The Lenovo ThinkPad A285, on the other hand, has a more robust set of ports, making it more versatile for university work.
University Workload and Gaming
While these older laptops may be fully capable of handling most academic tasks, it is worth considering your intended university workload. Students who will be using the laptop for gaming, video editing, or other resource-intensive applications may find that a newer laptop is more suitable. For academic needs, however, both the MacBook Air 2017 and the Lenovo ThinkPad A285 are solid choices, provided you are willing to manage the limitations of their age.
Alternative Options
Finally, do not overlook the Chromebook. With its long battery life and affordability, a Chromebook can be an excellent option for university students. It is particularly ideal for those who do not need to run resource-intensive applications and prefer a simplified user interface.
Recommendation Summary:
For academia: Both the MacBook Air 2017 and the Lenovo ThinkPad A285 are suitable for academic tasks but require careful consideration of the age of the hardware. For gaming or resource-intensive tasks: Neither of these older laptops is recommended for gaming, and a newer model would be preferable. For cost and battery life: A Chromebook may be a more affordable and practical option for university students who prioritize a long battery life and easy connectivity.Conclusion:
The choice between a 6 and 7-year-old laptop may seem daunting, but by carefully considering your specific needs and preferences, you can make an informed decision. Look around and see what others in your university are using, and don’t hesitate to consult with your peers for recommendations. Ultimately, the right laptop for university work is one that meets your current needs and supports your future academic and professional goals.