Why Did Apple Adopt the Butterfly Keyboard for New Macs 2016 and What Is Wrong with the Scissor Keyboard?
Apple's transition to the butterfly keyboard in 2016 for their new Mac models sparked a heated debate among users and analysts. Many wondered what was wrong with the beloved scissor mechanism that had served Apple's laptops for years. In this article, we will explore the reasons behind Apple's design choice and the potential implications for the future of laptop keyboards.
Design Choices and Durability
Apple claims that the butterfly keyboard is more durable than the scissor mechanism. The new design uses fewer parts, which theoretically reduces the chances of wear and tear, leading to fewer service costs for Apple. However, the adoption of the butterfly keyboard also led to a reduction in the throw distance, the distance from when you press the key to where it hits bottom.
This reduction in throw distance can be attributed to the need for Apple to reduce the thickness of their laptops. In 2016, the market was moving towards thinner devices, and Apple wanted to remain competitive. The butterfly mechanism allowed for a more compact design while still providing some level of usability and stability.
Training Users for New Keyboard Experiences
The lower throw distance of the butterfly keyboard raises the question of whether it is preparing users for a new typing experience. Apple may be training users to type on surfaces with little to no resistance, which could indicate a shift in their keyboard technology in the future.
Some speculate that Apple may be working on integrating a keyboard-like interface on the surface of the laptop, similar to the way the iPhone X displays its keyboard. This could mean that the traditional keyboard experience might be phased out entirely in certain models. The butterfly keyboard could be seen as a transitional design that prepares users for this change.
Stability and Clickiness
Another argument posited by proponents of the butterfly keyboard is that it provides more stability and clickiness, especially for keys with low travel. The scissor mechanism, while effective, has been criticized for lacking the tactile feedback that is crucial for experienced typists.
The butterfly mechanism, with its reinforced base, offers a more balanced and stable typing experience. This could be particularly beneficial for users who rely on accurate keystrokes and require a high level of tactile feedback.
The Future of Laptops and Keyboard Technology
As technology advances, the demand for thinner and more versatile laptops continues to grow. Apple's decision to adopt the butterfly keyboard can be seen as a strategic move to stay ahead in this competitive market. The reduction in throw distance and the emphasis on stability and clickiness may be signals of a trend towards more innovative and versatile keyboard designs.
However, this does not necessarily mean the end of traditional keyboards. The transition to new keyboard technologies often involves a period of adaptation for both users and manufacturers. Apple's move towards a more compact and stable design could be a step towards integrating more advanced features and perhaps merging the keyboard experience with other technologies, such as touchscreens and built-in displays.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Apple's adoption of the butterfly keyboard in 2016 was a strategic decision driven by a combination of factors, including the desire for a thinner design, lower service costs, and the need for a more balanced and stable typing experience. While some users may have initially been skeptical, the butterfly keyboard has shown promise in addressing the needs of modern computing. As technology continues to evolve, we can expect to see further innovations in keyboard design that will continue to push the boundaries of what is possible.